Items qualify for Free Shipping
Level up your look with the Cara loafer—constructed with brown leather uppers and perfectly chunky lugged soles. Standing 1 1/2" tall with rubber grip and CloudBound™ insoles, this go-with-anything style is both comfortable and supportive.
Join TOMS Rewards
Earn points for this purchase
Overall rating: 4.019231 / 5 from 1300 reviews.
The Cara Dark Brown Leather Loafer by TOMS is praised for its stylish look and good quality, though opinions on width, size, and heel vary. Customers appreciate the comfort and support, but some report sizing issues.
Review topics: ["size","fit","color","support","look","weight","length","price","quality","design","material","issues","comfort","style","shape","shoes","feel","construction","width","shipping","leather","height","snug","jeans","comfy","finish","band","pants","loafers","loafer"].
"Love the look and fit of these loafers. Very nice quality. They feel smooth. I would say they are a little bit on the narrow side. But not too bad. I should’ve sized up and I purchased them on a great sale. So unfortunately, I’m probably not gonna be able to get my size."
"I’ve had these loafers in my wishlist for a long time, waiting for a good sale. Completely worth the wait! Beautiful leather, comfortable from the start & they go with a variety of outfits. From pants, or jeans to dresses and skirts, the Cara loafer is a workhorse when finishing an outfit. A tailored shoe that lifts a casual outfit to polished & complete!"
"These loafers are so comfortable. I was able to wear them all day with no break-in time needed. I have a more narrow fit and these fit like a glove. Highly recommend!"
"super happy with these but definitely had to wear them around the house a bit with doubled up socks to stretch them out. They're quite narrow and I dont usually have an issue with the width of my shoes. The first day I wore them to work my feet were still feeling squeezed in from the tightness. But after another full work day they've loosened up. If I had sized up, the shoe would for sure be too long, already have space at the toes as it is and I'm a consistent 7. 5 that only sometimes sizes up to 8."
"Loved the look. But they just didn't hug my feet well enough to stay on. The heel was too loose for my heel even when I ordered the smaller size."
"Shoe fits very narrow with a stiffness that does not seem like it would improve over time. Liked the brown leapord print but the sole is very rugged. Had to return. Toms are normally my shoe to go to for comfort. This shoe is not comfortable."
"Love my new shoes. Fit true to size and are exactly what I wanted. They did seem a bit snug at first but stretched just slightly to make them the perfect fit!"
"I love them - I had to purchase a heel protector because they were rubbing a bit at the back of my feet, but they are super comfortable! Love these shoes!"
"I got these for work and I absolutely love them. My friend wears them all the time for her job and highly recommended. Also, super comfortable."
"I don't have a super wide foot, but I do need a wider toe box. The shoe was advertised as wide, but definitely just fit like a normal narrow/standard shoe. Return shipping is $15 - so basically I just ended up paying to try a pair of shoes on."
