"Very cute and very stiff. I have narrow feet, so the fit is very odd: my heel slips a little, but these were very tight across the top. I sat in a squat position for about 30 minutes to stretch them out, which helped quite a bit, but at the end of the day, it still feels good to take these off. I don’t regret the purchase and I do like them, but I would not recommend for someone with wider feet, which is why I'm rating these 3 stars (neutral)."
Overall rating: 4.0188384 / 5 from 1274 reviews.
AI Generated Review Summary
The Cara Black Leather Loafer by TOMS is praised for its quality and style, with a good reputation among customers. However, opinions on the fit and width vary, and some customers have mixed feelings about the heel. The color and look of the shoe are highly appreciated.
Summary topics
- Fit: 15%
- Size: 13%
- Color: 6%
- Quality: 7%
- Style: 5%
Review topics: [size, fit, length, support, color, quality, material, issues, look, feel, shape, shipping, comfort, design, style, pants, width, leather, height, price, snug, comfy, construction, shoes, finish, weight, band, loafers, loafer, feet].
Review highlights
- "A touch loose but great style and fit" —
- "Good quality, size fits well." —
- "Love the style, and the fit, wish they were a darker brown." —
Reviews
Fit
"I love Tom's and I love these shoes! I especially love the look for my office job. For some reason, no matter what style of shoe I buy from Tom's, they do not seem to fit properly foot-to-foot. My larger foot is my right foot. I wear a 9 or 9. 5 and with the way Tom's fit. My left foot fits perfectly, but my right is always too loose to where my right heal slips outwhile walking. Which again is odd because that is normally my bigger foot. Anyways, lovely shoes, but like any other style of Tom's, it just doesn't fit my right foot right."
Love the fit
"Love the look and fit of these loafers. Very nice quality. They feel smooth. I would say they are a little bit on the narrow side. But not too bad. I should’ve sized up and I purchased them on a great sale. So unfortunately, I’m probably not gonna be able to get my size."
"Good experience. Shoes were packaged well and arrived on time without damage. Very impressed."
Perfect fit
"Been eyeing these for a while and I love them. Fit perfect and comfortable"
Socks or no socks, that’s the question
"I like wearing socks but my socks fall when wearing them with these loafers. Frustrating and uncomfortable."
Great classic!
"I’ve had these loafers in my wishlist for a long time, waiting for a good sale. Completely worth the wait! Beautiful leather, comfortable from the start & they go with a variety of outfits. From pants, or jeans to dresses and skirts, the Cara loafer is a workhorse when finishing an outfit. A tailored shoe that lifts a casual outfit to polished & complete!"
Comfortable and great color!
"These loafers are so comfortable. I was able to wear them all day with no break-in time needed. I have a more narrow fit and these fit like a glove. Highly recommend!"
LOVE but also fairly narrow
"super happy with these but definitely had to wear them around the house a bit with doubled up socks to stretch them out. They're quite narrow and I dont usually have an issue with the width of my shoes. The first day I wore them to work my feet were still feeling squeezed in from the tightness. But after another full work day they've loosened up. If I had sized up, the shoe would for sure be too long, already have space at the toes as it is and I'm a consistent 7. 5 that only sometimes sizes up to 8."
Socks or no socks
"I like to wear socks but they fall when I wear them with these loafers"