Items qualify for Free Shipping
The Carolina Mary Jane: a modern and casual take on a timeless classic. This espadrille features the rope-wrapped platform of our signature Carolina with a feminine new mary jane strap and toe. Buckle them up for instant chic.
Join TOMS Rewards
Earn points for this purchase
Overall rating: 4.583871 / 5 from 310 reviews.
Carolina Mary Jane Espadrille Natural Yarn Dye shoes are praised for their great look and style, with many customers loving the fit and color. However, opinions on size vary, with some finding it true to size while others experience inconsistency.
Review topics: ["size","fit","strap","shoes","color","look","fabric","feet","comfort","style","pattern","mary janes","width","espadrilles","exchange","pair","toms","flats","footbed","return","brand","compliments","cushion","suede","side","break","print"].
"I got these for an outdoor summer wedding (needed flats) and they are just right. They are pretty and the woven detail dresses them up a notch. The footbed has a nice cushion. I thought they were a touch too small when I first put them on, but within an hour or two of wearing them, the size settled in and they are great. And they don’t make big feet look any bigger! Always a plus when you’re a size 12."
"The Mary Jane style is one of favorites and I love denim. I purchased my usual 7. 5 and they fit perfectly. The padded insole makes the shoe comfortable and I enjoy the extra height."
"I LOVE my Toms Leopard Mary Janes! They are so cute and comfortable, and I can wear them with so many outfits - dress down or dress up. IMPORTANT: Follow the sizing advice and order a whole size smaller than your regular size!!! If you do, you will be so happy! I wear a solid 8; bought size 7, and they are a perfect fit."
"VERY stiff, initially i thought they were too small but i realied the tow box was small and stuff. I used a small hammer to pound on the stitches at the top of the toe box and they were much more comfortable after that. Everything else fit fine, perhaps slightly on the smaller side, but I don’t think a size would make them less stiff. Just be prepared to break them in a bit and they are still becoming my favorite shoes!"
"I purchased these shoes due to all the positive reviews however, these were incredibly uncomfortable. I didn’t even wear them for a long period of time. I ended up with blisters all over my feet will never wear them again pretty expensive investment to have shoes that are so uncomfortable and will never be worn."
"Super cute summer shoes/espadrilles - very comfy - looking forward to wearing them with my summer dresses"
"Love these shoes! I had the leopard ones, and decided I needed the white ones for summer. Very comfortable, cute shoes!"
"I love the shoe but it sticks up above my toes because it is too deep. I bought a size smaller and it still had space between the top of my foot and the shoe. I kept them anyway because they are so cute."
"Sizing was horrible despite buying same size in a different shoe . Returned."
"I'll get the negative part out of the way first: I had to order three different sizes in this shoe before I got the right fit. I always wear a 6. 5 in Toms shoes. However, a 6. 5 in these was huge, and so was a 6 (which is what I wear in just about every other brand). Once I got a 5. 5, they fit just right. However, now I'm having trouble getting my labels to return the other two pairs. I'm waiting on customer service to reply back to help me with that issue. Now for the good part: these shoes are SO pretty and the perfect neutral to go with any color or pattern of my summer skirts and dresses. They're also extremely comfortable with excellent arch support: I wore for the first time on a day when I walked about 10,000 steps in them, and they were great. My only complaint is that the backs of the shoes were a bit stiff, so they rubbed my heels a little, but not enough to create blisters. Hopefully that will not be a problem over time."
